Alabama Jubilee: judges’ majority-agreement review
Cullman, Alabama · October 23–24, 2026
All figures below are calculated from your uploaded Alabama Jubilee results. This measures agreement among the judges’ cards. It does not establish which judge correctly assessed the horses’ performances.
1. Main scores: every class counts equally
For each class, I compared every possible pair of horses. A judge receives credit when their order matches the order preferred by at least two of the three judges. I then averaged the class percentages, giving each eligible class the same weight.
| Rank | Judge | Majority-agreement score |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Brent Grider | 95.54 / 100 |
| 2 | Amy Trimble | 92.29 / 100 |
| 3 | Amber Zahnd | 91.42 / 100 |
These are descriptive agreement scores, not official judging ratings or school grades.
What went into the calculation
The attachment contains 55 classes and 204 printed final placements. Those are horse appearances across classes, not 204 distinct horses.
I excluded:
- Five single-entry classes, because they provide no horse-to-horse comparison.
- Three classes with different entry-number sets, because the printed cards cannot be compared reliably without clarification.
That leaves 47 comparable classes, 182 horse appearances, and 314 horse-pair comparisons. Of those 47 classes, 19 had identical cards from all three judges and 28 contained some disagreement.
The judge columns rotate throughout the results. I followed each judge’s name in every class rather than assuming a fixed column position.
2. Who agreed most often on the winner?
Of the 47 eligible classes:
- 31 had the same first-place selection from all three judges.
- 15 had a two-to-one first-place decision.
- One had three different first-place selections.
That gives 46 classes with an identifiable majority first-place choice.
| Judge | Selected the majority winner | Agreement | Selected the majority winner in the 15 split decisions |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brent Grider | 44 of 46 | 95.65% | 13 of 15 |
| Amy Trimble | 38 of 46 | 82.61% | 7 of 15 |
| Amber Zahnd | 41 of 46 | 89.13% | 10 of 15 |
Brent has the strongest winner-agreement record in this comparison. Among the 15 two-to-one winner decisions, he was the dissenting judge twice, Amy eight times, and Amber five times.
The class with three different first-place choices was Three Year Old Mares/Geldings/WHTA Riders Cup. It is excluded from the majority-winner denominator because there was no shared first-place selection.
3. The alternative calculation puts Amy first
When all horse pairs are pooled together, larger classes contribute more comparisons. A seven-horse class supplies 21 pairs, while a two-horse class supplies only one.
| Judge | Agreed with the majority across all pairs | Agreement on the 86 disputed pairs only |
|---|---|---|
| Amy Trimble | 291 of 314 — 92.68% | 63 of 86 — 73.26% |
| Brent Grider | 288 of 314 — 91.72% | 60 of 86 — 69.77% |
| Amber Zahnd | 277 of 314 — 88.22% | 49 of 86 — 56.98% |
This is a meaningful distinction:
- Brent leads when each class has equal importance.
- Amy leads when each individual horse-pair comparison has equal importance.
- Amber ranks third under both of these overall measures.
The disputed-pair column removes the 228 comparisons on which all three judges agreed. It focuses on the decisions that actually divided the panel.
For consistency with your earlier report, I would keep equal-class weighting as the headline score and disclose the pooled comparison alongside it. Changing the weighting after seeing the results would make comparisons between shows harder to trust.
4. How closely did the cards match the published final order?
This is a separate measurement. Matching the published Final column is not always the same as agreeing with the two-of-three preference between individual horses.
| Judge | Exact matches to final placing | Entire card matched Final | Average distance from final placing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brent Grider | 149 of 182 — 81.87% | 34 of 47 classes | 0.242 places |
| Amy Trimble | 141 of 182 — 77.47% | 31 of 47 classes | 0.275 places |
| Amber Zahnd | 129 of 182 — 70.88% | 31 of 47 classes | 0.396 places |
For the last column, a horse placed first by a judge and third in the Final contributes a distance of two places. Lower averages mean closer agreement with the published results.
Brent leads all three of these final-order measures.
5. The individual decisions most worth reviewing
These examples are taken directly from the supplied cards. They identify specific differences that could be examined against the class video and applicable judging criteria; disagreement alone does not establish a bad decision.
Amber Zahnd: I’m Gemini, Three Year Old Stallions
I’m Gemini, entry 506, received:
| Brent Grider | Amy Trimble | Amber Zahnd | Final |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1st | 1st | 6th | 1st |
This is the largest individual judge-to-Final difference in the comparable results: five places.
Amber agreed with the pairwise majority on 12 of 21 comparisons, or 57.14%, in this class. Amy agreed on all 21; Brent agreed on 20.
That makes this a particularly useful class for a detailed review. The question is concrete: what did Amber observe that led her to put the horse sixth when both colleagues placed him first?
Amber Zahnd: Walking Horse Championship
I’m Charlie Daniels, entry 620, received:
| Brent Grider | Amy Trimble | Amber Zahnd | Final |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1st | 1st | 3rd | 1st |
There were three listed horses. Brent and Amy submitted the same complete order. Amber placed their first choice third.
Her majority agreement in this class was one of three pairs, or 33.33%.
Amy Trimble: Racking Specialty Action Youth
Sound of Silence, entry 616, received:
| Brent Grider | Amy Trimble | Amber Zahnd | Final |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1st | 3rd | 1st | 1st |
Brent and Amber submitted identical cards. Amy agreed with the majority on one of three pairs.
Amy’s broader pattern deserves a balanced description: she differed from the majority winner more often than either colleague, while agreeing with the majority on more pooled horse-pair comparisons overall.
Brent Grider: Alabama Ladies Auxiliary Specialty
Starpower CC, entry 669, received:
| Brent Grider | Amy Trimble | Amber Zahnd | Final |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3rd | 1st | 1st | 1st |
This was one of Brent’s two departures from the majority first-place selection. His first choice was Strong Ambush.
His other winner dissent was in Racking Specialty Action Open, where he placed Cash N Black first and See You at the Finish second. Amy and Amber placed See You at the Finish first.
Brent also had a substantial difference in Racking Pleasure: he placed Papas First Choice seventh, compared with Amy’s third, Amber’s second, and the published fourth.
6. The three classes excluded because the printed entries do not reconcile
| Class | What the attachment shows | Treatment |
|---|---|---|
| Mares/Geldings/WHTA Riders Cup | Brent’s second-place number is 585; Amy, Amber, and Final show 587. | Excluded without changing either number. |
| Amateur Specialty | Brent’s second-place number is 574; Amy, Amber, and Final show 573. | Excluded without assuming a correction. |
| Racking Trail Pleasure | The displayed cards contain different sets of entries. Amy includes 618 but omits 690 from the final set. Amber includes 618 and 692 but omits 676 and 691. | Excluded because missing ranks cannot be established. |
The first two may be transcription or entry-number errors. The attachment alone does not establish where those discrepancies originated.
The Racking Trail Pleasure differences could also arise from judges selecting different horses for a limited number of printed placings. They should not automatically be labeled errors.
Excluding the entire affected class keeps all three judges on the same comparison population.
7. Why “majority opinion” and “final order” must stay separate
Two classes contain a circular majority preference.
In Three Year Old Mares/Geldings/WHTA Riders Cup:
- Amy and Amber placed Seger ahead of Justified by Faith 4G.
- Brent and Amy placed She’s on the Money ahead of Seger.
- Brent and Amber placed Justified by Faith 4G ahead of She’s on the Money.
Those preferences form a circle. No single finishing order can satisfy all three two-of-three preferences simultaneously.
A similar circle appears in Racking Pleasure among Don’t Break My Heart, Armed Cowboy, and Papas First Choice.
Across the 47 comparable classes, the published final order differs from the pairwise majority on three comparisons in those two classes. That does not, by itself, establish a tabulation error. Determining compliance would require the applicable tally rules and relevant records. I have not inferred a designated call judge from the order of the printed columns.
8. Removing the racking classes preserves the main ranking
Because the attachment includes both walking and racking divisions, I also calculated the scores after removing every eligible class whose title begins with “Racking.”
The remaining 34 non-racking classes produce:
| Judge | Equal-class majority-agreement score |
|---|---|
| Brent Grider | 96.57 / 100 |
| Amy Trimble | 93.98 / 100 |
| Amber Zahnd | 92.07 / 100 |
Under the pooled-pair method for those same classes, Brent and Amy tie at 215 of 229 comparisons, or 93.89%. Amber records 199 of 229, or 86.90%.
What deserves attention before publication
The first priority is to verify the three excluded classes against the original cards or a corrected results record. The strongest performance-review examples are I’m Gemini in Three Year Old Stallions, I’m Charlie Daniels in the Walking Horse Championship, Sound of Silence in Racking Specialty Action Youth, and Starpower CC in Alabama Ladies Auxiliary Specialty.
The supported conclusion is precise: Brent was closest to the panel under your established equal-class method and strongest on majority-winner agreement. Amy had the fewest minority decisions when all horse pairs were counted equally. Amber had the largest single placing departure and the lowest overall agreement under both weighting methods.










